Questlove Breaks Down The Daft Punk Sampling Controversy

Questlove outlines crucial flaws in the sampling system that almost ensure musicians and their catalogs get ripped off.

Earlier this week, a Los Angeles Times report detailed the account of Eddie Johns, a disco-era singer and musician who claimed he’d yet to receive any royalties from, being sampled on the 2000 Daft Punk single, “One More Time.”

The story, which dove into the hard times Johns had fallen upon in the decades since he released “More Spell On You” (the song sampled on the French duo’s breakout single,) and how his catalog was acquired by a French label larger than the one he’d released his lone album on, was almost instantly picked up by a number of music outlets (including ours.) But much like the original LA Times piece, none of the subsequent reporting on the mishandling of Johns’ check(s) was able to determine how and why Johns’ catalog, like those of countless musicians, was severed from its creator so completely that it took 20 years and a major publication’s story to bring the oversight to the attention of the label currently administrating the rights to Johns’ music.

If it sounds like a lot, that’s because it is. And to get to the bottom of it, you need either a juris doctor in licensing and publishing or a cool thirty years of submitting and overseeing sample clearances. Questlove, as it happens, falls squarely in the latter category. And the Roots drummer’s take on the controversy surrounding Johns and Daft Punk’s dispute comes with an outline of the crucial flaws in the sampling system that almost ensure musicians and their catalogs get ripped off. In a lengthy Twitter thread posted on Friday, Questlove broke down how licensing and publishing administration is filled with opportunistic middlemen that hawk prospective catalog acquisitions from small regional labels. “The real culprit in the sampling controversy always lies with the invisible middlemen who acquire (sometimes legally) dormant catalogues that are up for grabs,” Questo writes.

The drummer goes on to explain how some notorious catalog collectors are actually an exception to a predatory norm. “A cat like Michael Jackson actually does right by his acquirements by purchasing songs from publishing houses and returning them to their rightful owner (Little Richard, Sly—-stop crying about the Beatles yall at the time they had a chance to purchase & scoffed & decided against),” he adds before explaining how the licensing system is effectively designed to present an artist’s publishing as a convenient cash grab in dire circumstances by mandating an artist re-register their songs with a publishing administrator within a certain amount of time in order to maintain the rights to their own music.

Questlove caps the thread with a number of propositions that would level the playing field for sample-based producers and the creators of their source material, including flat-rate sampling fees that allocate a fixed amount for both the labels (as a “tax,”) and the musicians who played on the sampled song who are not members of the American Federation of Musicians, a somewhat controversial union.

Read through Questlove’s take on the sampling controversy below.


Zo is a staff writer at Okayplayer where he covers music.

Published by

Recent Posts

Nikole Hannah-Jones Hopes You Have a Red Pill ‘Matrix’ Moment With ‘1619 Project’ Docuseries

Hulu and Nikole Hannah-Jones turned the robust 1619 Project, moving pieces of journalism into a… Read More

January 26, 2023

Watch the Latest ‘Shazam! Fury of the Gods’ Trailer

The new trailer for Shazam! Fury of the Gods has released, with Billy Batson and his… Read More

January 26, 2023

Cordae Says He Has a J. Cole-Produced Project with Anderson .Paak

Rapper Cordae says he's recorded a project worth of material with Anderson .Paak, all of… Read More

January 26, 2023

These Are the Most Streamed TV Shows of 2022

With Stranger Things leading the pack, Osark, Wednesday, NCIS and more were some of the most-streamed… Read More

January 26, 2023

Aaliyah Fans Are Petitioning for Her to Be Inducted Into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame

Aaliyah fans have started a petition for the late vocalist to be inducted into the… Read More

January 26, 2023

Eddie Murphy Talks Bringing “Music and Stand-Up” to His Next Live Show

Comic legend and You People star Eddie Murphy recently spoke to Complex about plans for… Read More

January 26, 2023