The Five Biggest Takeaways From Sgt. Jon Mattingly’s Breonna Taylor ‘GMA’ Interview

In a two-hour interview, Sgt. John Mattingly shares his perspective of the night that left Breonna Taylor dead.

Breonna Taylor is now attached to me for the rest of my life,” says Sgt. Jon Mattingly, one of the officers who was involved in the botched raid that ended Taylor’s life. 

In a Good Morning America interview released this morning with co-anchor Michael Strahan, Mattingly provides his recollection of the evening and tells his side of the story. The platform he’s been given provides him a space to carve out his own facts, this is the first time he’s spoken out in the past seven months. 

Below we’re sharing the biggest takeaways from his interview.

A neighbor allegedly tried to stop the raid

During the interview, Mattingly expresses that when the team of seven officers reached the porch of Taylor’s apartment, a neighbor came out and began arguing with Hankinson. He remembers the neighbor saying something close to, “‘She’s a good girl, leave her alone.” The officers were aiming to find money and drugs that could be linked to an ongoing investigation into Jamarcus Glover, Taylor’s ex-boyfriend. 

When the officers entered the apartment, Mattingly saw two figures

He then shared before entering the apartment, the officers announced themselves. But, according to 12 witnesses including Taylor’s boyfriend, Kenneth Walker, the officers did not. Once the officers entered the apartment by force, he said he saw two figures at the end of the hall. Following this moment, he claims he heard a shot and felt a burning sensation in his leg. Walker reportedly shot him with a “warning shot,” this led to Mattingly shooting four return shots. This led to 32 shots ringing off, these shots led to Taylor’s death. He also adds here that if the seven officers stormed in with a no-knock warrant, that Taylor would still be alive today.

Mattingly wasn’t aware of Breonna Taylor’s death until the following morning

He alleges he didn’t learn of her death until the morning after the raid when he was out of surgery for his injury. Mattingly makes it clear that it was a mistake to assume Taylor was at her apartment alone. He also notes that he believes she’d be alive if the officers had given her and Walker more time to collect themselves.

Mattingly doesn’t believe the fatal shooting has anything to do with race

At one point, Mattingly shares empathy for Taylor’s family. But, he also manages to throw in bigoted ideals in regards to violence inflicted on African Americans. “It’s not a race thing like people want to try to make it out to be. It’s not. This is a point where we were doing our job, we gave too much time when we go in, I get shot, we returned fire,” he said. “This is not us going, hunting somebody down. This is not kneeling on a neck. It’s nothing like that.” It’s difficult to stomach these sentences as anything less than racist.

Breonna Taylor, George Floyd and Ahmaud Arbery are different types of cases, according to Mattingly

Mattingly’s depiction of George Floyd was also alarming. “This is not relatable to George Floyd. This is nothing like that.” He added, “It’s not Ahmaud Arbery. It’s nothing like it. These are two totally different types of incidences.” 

This blatant erasure clarifies the officer’s viewpoints and could point to the fact that he doesn’t value Black bodies. The publicized deaths that have driven protestors and activists to organize throughout generations are not isolated incidents. 

Immediately after the Good Morning America interview aired, users on Twitter began sharing their take on it. There were quite a few reactions that stood out, you can read a few of them below.

The Latest

At the moment, a grand juror who was granted the ability to speak out about the case has divulged that the grand jury “didn’t agree that [Taylor’s] fatal shooting was justified,” per NBC. This news comes after a Kentucky judge ordered records in the proceedings to be released.  

Robyn Mowatt

Robyn Mowatt is a Staff Writer at Okayplayer where she covers culture, music, and fashion. You can see what's on her mind on Twitter at @robyn_mowatt.

Published by
Robyn Mowatt

Recent Posts

What’s AP African American Studies and Why Has Florida Banned It?

Here's what to know about AP African American Studies and why the course has become… Read More

February 1, 2023

D’Angelo Will Be Featured on Audible’s ‘Words + Music’ Series

D'Angelo and Jazmine Sullivan have joined Audible's Words + Music roster, each artist hosting a… Read More

February 1, 2023

A ‘King of the Hill’ Revival Is Coming to Hulu

Hulu is reviving beloved Fox animated sitcom King of the Hill, with co-creator Mike Judge… Read More

February 1, 2023

For Freestyle Fellowship, Their Grammy Nomination Is “A Long Time Coming”

Freestyle Fellowship members Aceyalone and Self Jupiter spoke about the Grammy nomination, releasing old and… Read More

February 1, 2023

Dr. Dre Celebrates 30 Years of ‘The Chronic’ By Bringing it Back to Streaming

Dr. Dre is celebrating the 30th anniversary of his debut album, The Chronic, with a 30th… Read More

February 1, 2023

Netflix Reveals How it Will Crackdown on Password Sharing

Netflix has updated their FAQ pages with details about exemptions and rules on password-sharing within… Read More

February 1, 2023