Cyntoia Brown’s Lawyers Are Seeking To Overturn Her Life Sentence

Photo Credit: Jae S. Lee for The Tennessean

Lawyers for Cyntoia Brown, the Nashville woman who was imprisoned at the age of 16 for killing a child predator who paid her for sex, have filed an appeal in federal court challenging her sentence.

READ: The Story Of Cyntoia Brown, A Child Sex Slave Imprisoned For Killing Her Abuser, Has Resurfaced

In a report from The Tennessean, Brown’s lawyers are asking the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals to weigh the constitutionality of her life sentence and to consider whether Brown is actually innocent because she lacked the sufficient mental capacity for a murder conviction at the time of the crime.

In the appeal, Brown’s lawyers argued that she may not survive until her parole hearing at age 69 and that the Supreme Court had directed states to provide “some meaningful opportunity to obtain release.”

“The half-century wait before Cyntoia Brown has a meaningful opportunity to demonstrate her ‘maturity and rehabilitation’ is insufficient to satisfy the minimum constitutional requirement mandated by the Supreme Court,” the appeal said. “This was a seriously mentally impaired girl, subject to the immaturity and impulsiveness of all juveniles but to a much greater degree, who had been abandoned by her parents and whose only refuge was a pimp who sexually and physically abused her.”

The inclusion of Brown being “mentally impaired” references an expert who testified in Brown’s sentencing hearing, who noted that the now 29-year-old may have suffered from fetal alcohol syndrome disorder in utero, affecting her mental ability.

Previously, a legal expert had said that it is possible Brown could see an early release because of the newfound attention surrounding her case.

Speaking with PEOPLE magazine, University of Memphis professor Steve Mulroy said that Brown’s life sentence could be commuted some time this year. Although commutations are considered a rarity in Tennessee (less than one percent of those requests are granted), Mulroy believes Brown’s outcome could be different just based upon the advocacy surrounding her case.

“I think the national focus helps,” Mulroy said. “There is also a compelling argument for commutation here. The governor only has a year left in office, and has tended to be more moderate than your average Tennessee Republican, who are tough on law and order issues. I suppose there’s a chance it could happen.”

Tennessee Governor Bill Haslam is currently looking into Brown’s case. Haslam’s administration has begun gathering information on Brown but said that a decision to grant her clemency is unlikely to come until this year.

Source: The Tennessean

Elijah C. Watson

Elijah Watson serves as Okayplayer's News & Culture Editor. When he's not writing he's listening to Sade and crying or watching My Hero Academia with his partner.

Published by
Elijah C. Watson

Recent Posts

Memphis Police Releases Bodycam Footage of Deadly Tyre Nichols Beating

The city of Memphis has released four videos showing the beating that killed Tyre Nichols… Read More

January 27, 2023

Best Songs of The Week: ft. Kari Faux, Lil Yachty and More

The Round-Up is Okayplayer’s weekly playlist of the best songs in the worlds of hip-hop… Read More

January 27, 2023

‘The Simpsons,’ ‘Family Guy’ and ‘Bob’s Burgers’ Gets Extension for Two Additional Seasons

Fox has given two-season renewals to animated favorites The Simpsons, Family Guy and Bob's Burgers… Read More

January 27, 2023

Consequence Says He’s ‘Disgusted’ With Pusha T Cutting Ties With Kanye West

In an interview with The Art of Dialogue, longtime G.O.O.D. Music act Consequence accused Pusha… Read More

January 27, 2023

A Book On Erykah Badu Album ‘New Amerykah Part Two’ Is Coming in 2024

Written by Karmeryn Alexa Carter, a book on 2020 Erykah Badu album New Amerykah Part Two… Read More

January 27, 2023

7 New Hip-Hop & Neo-Soul Albums You Should Be Listening To (Week of January 27)

Styles P and Lil Yachty have dropped projects on this New Music Friday. Additional releases… Read More

January 27, 2023